Vasilisa Neshataeva
English Russian
English Russian

The Interview: Vasilisa Neshataeva, author of the book “Cultural Property. Value and Law”


Vasilisa Neshataeva
Vasilisa Neshataeva
  • A buyer is a vulnerable figure in art transactions, and therefore he should independently consider risks and take care for the protection of his interests;
  • A form evidence of a good-faith buyer is checking an artwork in the stolen cultural property registers;
  • Public cultural property registers are helpful to fight illicit trade of cultural property;
  • The codes of professional ethics for art dealers facilitate self-regulation of the art-market and help reduce risks in art transactions.

Regulatory measures affecting Russian and international art market is an important objective of providing transparency of art transactions. Another important issue in art transactions is professional ethics of sellers, which is documented in the recommendations and guidelines for professional art businesses.

Vasilisa Neshataeva, Phd, AP International law department of the Russian State University of Justice, author of the book “Cultural Property. Value and Law” (available in Russian and recommended to all interested in art business) speaks about the possibility of creating national control in the Russian art market, protection of a buyer and liabilities of a seller.

– Buyer-seller relationships in the art market are based on the principle “caveat emptor”, which implies legal and financial risks to be carried by a buyer. What kind of legal liabilities should be carried by a seller in such environment? Is there any difference in legal liabilities carried by an owner of an artwork being sold and an agent?

– The principle “caveat emptor” means “Let the buyer beware”. Considering the art market is often free from the government control (for example, in Russia such business activity is not licensed) a buyer remains a vulnerable figure. A buyer should independently analyse legal and financial risks of an art transaction.

It is possible to stipulate the measures of civil liability of a seller in a contract in accordance with law applicable to the art transaction (for example, the transactions where an owner sells an artwork are executed as a contract of sale, and those featuring an agent via a commission contract). When entering into a relationship with a big auction house it is important to be aware that such entities usually use standard contracts where legal liability of the seller is strictly limited.

Besides that, bad faith seller may be hold criminally liable for illicit trafficking in cultural property, should a sold artwork turn out a forgery or stolen cultural property. However, a serious evidentiary basis is essential to hold a seller liable.

In case a seller neglects his liabilities, a buyer may appeal to the corresponding professional association and file a complaint. Unfortunately, not all sellers become members of such associations. Nevertheless, the leading players in the art market are not likely to risk their reputation.

In any case I would like to encourage the collectors to independently estimate and forecast all the risks related to transactions in cultural property. It is better to be prepared properly in advance, rather than to deal with long-term dispute settlement with additional financial expenses later.

– How important is the role of cultural property registers in combating the theft, illicit trafficking and forgeries of cultural property? Is creation of a national cultural property register possible in Russia? May a purchaser be considered diligent if an object prior to acquisition is checked with one or several art and antique databases including international?

– Promotion of public cultural property databases may enhance the measures against illicit trafficking in cultural property. Such practical experience already exists in some countries. Nevertheless in Russia such initiative attempted in the form of the draft law “About trafficking in cultural property on the territory of Russia” has failed. Many experts warn about possible negative consequences of the implementation of such law and the existence of a specialised art and antique register. In particular, such measure is regarded by the art business community as excessive control and reduction of trade in cultural property. However, such initiative may be implemented in Russia.

Nevertheless, I suppose that a public register of stolen cultural property (like private database The Art Loss Register) may become a good compromise allowing efficient cooperation between the state and the art business community. It is necessary to remember that we already live in new reality: Russia is a member of the supranational integration union – Eurasian Economic Union, together with Armenia, Belorussia, Kazakhstan and Kirgizia. Eurasian Economic Union exists within a single border. With the existence of such union, where supranational bodies take charge of economic and legal matters of the member states, it would be useful to create such a register on the level of the Eurasian Economic Union. Certainly, it would be difficult to technically implement such universal database. That is why even drafting this idea would take time.

The definition of “good faith purchaser” of cultural property from Russian perspective should be reviewed as a general term and its’ specification is to be determined by the court according to the circumstances of every individual case. The rules of good faith purchasing are being regulated by the Civil Code of the Russian Federation art. 302, which proclaims the principle “did not know/could not know”. Naturally the court would consider all circumstances of the case.

Scrupulous investigation of the provenance made by a buyer before the purchase (also using existing databases) would constitute the proof of diligence of a buyer, however it would make only a part of the whole issue.

It should be remembered that a Russian citizen might become involved in the litigation regarding cultural property on the territory of another state. Such cases are regulated by the law of that another state, and not by the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Different countries have own definition of “good faith purchaser” and the use of certain databases may be considered insufficient measure of provenance investigation of the disputed cultural property.

– The Responsible Art Market initiative (RAM) (established by Christie's and other members, such as SGS, Seydoux & Associés Fine Art, University of Geneva, etc.) is intended to change and raise due diligence standards in the art and antique market. The Guidelines on combatting Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing issued by RAM in January 2017 contain step-by-step guidelines on buyer-seller interaction, as well as “Red Flag List” for typical situations indicting suspicious transactions. How this initiative may influence Russian art market? Could it change existing relationships between Western sellers and Russian buyers? How it may change behaviour of Russian buyers? Could such guidelines be applicable to the Russian art market, and should a similar initiative be adopted in Russia?

– The field of cultural property trade is very sensitive, as it involves many players of the art market (governments, private individuals, museums etc.). In this relation all initiatives of tight legal regulation on international and supranational levels lie through difficult and thorny path, and thus may culminate in a declarative document only. In the attempt to reach self-regulation of the art market the trend of adopting various recommendations by the professional art market community is increasing. Such initiatives are important as they frame professional ethics. However as such these guidelines are a mere recommendation for the art market businesses rather than a normative legal act. Nevertheless, the parties may agree to adopt these rules in the contract and make them compulsory; such practice would make the trade in cultural property more transparent. I would like to refer to the International Code of Ethics for Dealers in Cultural Property, developed in 1999 by UNESCO. Although compliance with this Code is not compulsory, art. 8 states the sellers may jointly sign this Code and assign the authority responsible for the monitoring of compliance with the code. In case of noncompliance and misconduct of sellers with the code, the authority dealing with a complaint carries out an investigation and publishes corresponding results.

Certainly, the codes of professional ethics build confidence in the art market.


ALL ARTICLES
Paintings of European artists of the XV-XIXth centuries will be among the top lots at the Schuler Auktionen summer sale 24-28 June 2019. The work of the prominent animalist painter Alfred de Dreux (1810-1860), a vivid still life of Giacomo Fardella di Calvello (1624-1706), a high-skilled realistic portrait of Jan Anthonisz van Ravesteyn (1572-1657), Alpine landscape of Franz Richard Unterberger (1838-1902), two works of Carl Spitzweg (1808-1885) with convincing provenance and the paintings of other artists will be featured at the upcoming auction.  Next...
  • Views: 83
During the period 24-28 June 2019 the Schuler Auktionen will be auctioning Russian icons XVII – XIX centuries as part of their traditional summer sale. Among the lots to be auctioned are XVII century “Annunciation”, XVIII century “St. Georges”, XIX century “Our Lady of Kazan” with pearl basma oklad, XIX century “St. Nicholas”, XVIII century “Harrowing of Hell”, a large icon “The Great Feasts” c. 1800, “Hodegetria” c. 1800, XIX century tryptich “The founder of a temple” and XIX century “Christ Pantocrator”.  Next...
  • Views: 73
On June 5th, 2019 leading Russian art auction house MacDougall’s is hosting their next auction in London and offering rare masterpieces of Russian artists. The highlights include Boris Kustodiev’s (1878–1927) “Bakhchisarai” featuring rare for the artist Oriental subject, “Young Dreams (Tsesarevich)” created by the master of Russian history and folklore art Victor Vasnetsov (1848–1926), “Portrait of Alexander Bozheryanov” by the prominent Russian graphic artist Yury Annenkov (1889–1974), “Portrait of Count Nikita Ivanovich Panin” by Fedor Rokotov (c. 1735-1808), “Santi Apostoli, Venezia” by Petr Konchalovsky (1876–1956), “Landscape with Skiers” by Konstantin Yuon (1875–1958). Furthermore, the Imperial Porcelain Factory dessert plates from the Dowry Service of Grand Duchess Alexandra Nikolaevna (1825–1844) will be offered at the upcoming sale.  Next...
  • Views: 10103
On May 21st, 22nd and 23rd, 2019 the Genevan auction house Piguet will be offering Swiss and fashion watches as well as haute couture bags at their traditional spring auction, and from the 10th to the 20th of May 2019 at their online auction. Among the brands featured are Breitling, Tissot, Rolex, Jaeger-LeCoultre, Patek Philippe, Hermes, Chanel, Christian Dior, Celine and other.  Next...
  • Views: 6527
On May 21st, 22nd and 23rd, 2019, the Genevan auction house Piguet will be hosting their spring auction and offering important works of the renowned artists from the XIX-XXth centuries. The auction will feature three works from the “pearly” period in the career of Pierre-Auguste Renoir (1841-1919), the works of Henri Baptiste Lebasque (1865-1937), Edgar Degas (1834-1917), Honoré Daumier (1808-1879), Emil Schumacher (1912-1999), Jean Dubuffet (1901-1985), Alberto Giacometti (1901-1966), Salvador Dali (1904-1989) as well as "Jeune fille au chapeau interrompant sa broderie" from the master of pastels Jean Étienne Liotard (1702-1789).  Next...
  • Views: 7053
On March 28th, 2019, the German auction house Hampel Fine Art Auctions will be putting up rare works from Repin, Shishkin and Aivazovsky together with icons from the XIXth century and decorative art. The highlights: Ilya Repin (1844-1930) “Portrait of a lady with red rose”, Ivan Shishkin (1832-1898) “Interior with young woman at a table in front of window”, Ivan Aivazovsky (1817-1900) “Ship in distress” and “Turkish pavilion on riverside with men praying at full moon”.  Next...
  • Views: 7109
During the period from the 18th to the 23rd of March, 2019, the Swiss auction house Schuler Auktionen will be putting up Russian icons from the XVI-XVIII centuries and pieces of decorative arts at the upcoming auction. Among the top lots are some Russian cloisonné enamel pieces from the XIXth century, as well as a collection of Faberge-inspired works with a Bouquet of Lilies Clock Egg, made after the model by Faberge, which was gifted by the Emperor Nicholas II to his wife Alexandra Fyodorovna, and currently held in the Kremlin Armoury.  Next...
  • Views: 6901
During the period from the 18th to the 23rd of March, 2019, the Swiss auction house Schuler Auktionen will be offering works of European painters from the XVI-XIX centuries at the upcoming sale. Eduard von Grützner’s (Gross-Karlowitz, 1846 – Munich, 1925) “Rauenthaler” tasting wine is among the top lots together with the works of religious art by Hendrick van Somers (Lockeren, 1607 – Naples, 1655), Gaudenzio Ferrari (1477/78, Valduggia–Milan, 1546), Giovanni Ghisolfi (Milan, 1623 – Rome, 1683) and other renowned European painters.  Next...
  • Views: 5384
During the period from the 2nd to the 14th of March, 2019, until 21:00 (GMT+1) the Genevan auction house Piguet is hosting their online auction featuring following categories: Contemporary art, Middle East and Far East art, Canes, Light and furniture of the XXth century, Leather accessorise, Watches, Watches under 400 CHF, Decorative arts, Porcelain, Swiss painters , Oriental rugs and carpets. The delivery of purchased lots around the world is carried out by the auction house.  Next...
  • Views: 6827